Wow, Top Animal Behaviorist Say’s It OK To Use A Shock Collar, Go Figure

I don’t know how many times I started writing a post about all the debates surrounding this whole positive vs dominance or negative reinforcement, behavior modification training. Right of the bat let me tell you that positive reinforcement will accomplish the behavior goals you are seeking the vast majority of time. It’s a small percentage of the dogs out there, that have to be educated… ahh, lets say a different way. I feel I should remind you that even though it’s a small percentage of dogs that need some type of negative reinforcement to modify those undesirable behaviors, we’re still taking about millions of dogs every year. Oddly enough that kind of coincides with the millions of dogs being euthanized every year, in animal shelters or at the dog owners veterinary clinic.

We have here at spirit animal sanctuary about 90 dogs, and even these guys who were suppose to be the worst of the worst, behaviorally wise anyway, you know for biting, fear aggression, human aggression, animal aggression and food aggression ( yea, I don’t say, “resource guarding” for toys, treats, bones or food). Even these dogs responded positively to my positive reinforcement techniques, most of them anyway, some of them I had to get the message across by acting more like the big bad wolf.

Positive reinforcement works almost all of the time, but almost, is not good enough when a dogs life is at stake.

Alright I’ve kept you wondering long enough about the title of this post, well here it is. The book is called, ” Domestic animal behavior for veterinarians and animal scientists ” By Katherine A. Houpt, VMD, PhD, Professor of physiology and director of the Animal Behavior Clinic, Cornell University College of Veterinary Medicine in addition to being a diplomate of the American College of Veterinarian Behaviorists. ©2005 Blackwell Publishing.

In Chapter 1, page 20 under behavior problems excessive barking in the second paragraph, Ms. Houpt in her book mentions a couple of positive reinforcement methods that may help alleviate the dogs barking before going onto a more adverse or negative methods, when the positive approach doesn’t have the desired results.

She mentions trying a water gun or lemon juice squirted in the dog’s mouth, before talking  about a citronella collar and finally an electric (no bark) shock collar. And finally she mentions as a last resort, a cordectomy (debarking).

So you see,  even one of the most respected animal behaviorist on the planet, is essentially telling you that sometimes you need a little something more than positive reinforcement to stop unwanted dog behaviors.

You can read it for yourself at this link.

The Spirit Dog

© copyright 2010 a.s.papszycki

5 Responses

  1. I’ll admit. I was never a fan of the “shock” collar. I never think of it as an “electrical shock” as a lot of people think. It’s more like Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENs) which my mom had used for her back problems.

    My girlfriend got one for Dino (I think if you hit him on the head with a bat, he would still jump on you and lick your face!). She used it probably three times. Now, all she has to do is put the collar on him and he keeps four on the floor. Doesn’t even hit the switch.

    So, I’d rather not use it if I didn’t have to, but if nothing else truly doesn’t work, it’s worth a shot.

    We both tried it on our selves (our arms), first. She actually went to the highest setting! I…chickened out…


  2. When we first brought Spencer home, we lived in an apartment and he and Sable began playing and barking and barking and barking, all day long while we were at work. Our landlord told us this had to stop or we would lose our apartment. I was so afraid bc it is hard enough to find an apartment that will allow one dog but two pitbulls?? Forget it. I called the trainer from the shelter and she said to get shock collars. I said “Isn’t that mean?” and without missing a beat, she said “Not as mean as surrendering your two dogs at a shelter bc you lost your apartment.”
    Wise woman. I bought them, used them and protected my family and home. Once they learned they couldn’t bark with the collars on, they didn’t.

  3. Hello Michele,

    Nice to have you back.

    Happy Mothers Day

  4. Hi Alan it been a long time….look out for me I am making a comeback in July when my husband deploys…your site looks great 🙂

  5. Thank you for this post. Tools and techniques of all kinds work. Outcomes depend on the person applying the tool or technique. Sanity in the profession of dog training can be hard to find sometimes. Appreciate you giving light to a subject that too few wish to acknowledge.
    Happy training,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: